Argyle Lift Articles | Argyle Intelligence

From PPO to Fee-for-Service: How One Dental Practice Grew Collections from $2M to $6M

Written by Jenny Tubo | Nov 20, 2026, 12:49:13 AM

“How do I get off the PPO hamster wheel?” I hear this question from practice owners all the time, and I get it. I’ve been there. The good news is that moving from a PPO model to a true fee-for-service (FFS) model is absolutely doable. The catch? It’s not something you want to jump into quickly. It takes financial planning, a team that’s all in and a thoughtful game plan for talking with your patients.

In this article, I’ll walk you through how we made that move in one practice. Over five years, we dropped our insurance contracts, kept the trust of our team and patients, and grew annual collections from $2 million to $6 million. Here’s how we prepared, what happened along the way and what I’d tell any owner thinking about doing the same.

$500Kwritten off each year under PPO contracts
3–6 mo.of salaries and expenses held in reserve
$2M → $6Mannual collections within five years

The Hidden Cost of Staying In-Network

Back in 2015, I started digging into the financials of a dental practice that, by most measures, was doing great. We were producing $2.5 million a year. But we were only collecting $2 million.

So where did the other $500,000 go? It wasn’t slow-paying accounts or unpaid balances. It was money we were required to write off because of our PPO contracts. We’d done the work, and that revenue just vanished. I was shocked, and that was the moment I started planning our exit.

Not everyone was on board. Our consultants pushed back hard. We were in a relatively low-income area, and they were convinced we’d lose our entire patient base. I understood the worry, but I also knew our practice. We weren’t a run-of-the-mill, in-and-out office. We offered premium service, exceptional dentistry, and we genuinely cared for our patients. We knew that our revenue should reflect that.

Getting Ready to Drop Your PPOs

First, we had to be realistic about what would happen. Some patients were going to leave for an in-network office where their cleanings would cost them nothing out of pocket. Who could blame them? When you’ve been conditioned not to pay for treatment, it is hard to make that shift. We knew that fewer patients meant a lighter schedule, and a lighter schedule meant team members with less to do.

So, do you let people go? Not necessarily. We didn’t. But that’s a decision to make ahead of time, with a clear head, not in a panic after a slow month.

I understood that we needed a safety net. I decided we wouldn’t notify a single insurance carrier until we had three to six months of salaries and expenses in reserves. That cushion kept us from making rushed decisions if money got tight after the switch.

Bringing Your Team Along

Once the money side was in place and we had a plan, we sat down with the team and showed them exactly what our insurance contracts were costing us. When they realized that 20 to 30 percent of what they worked so hard to produce every day was simply being written off to the insurance companies, they were frustrated too. That frustration turned into real support. It wasn’t just the owner’s decision anymore; it was everyone’s.

From there, we made sure every team member had clear, consistent talking points. Whether a patient asked at the front desk, in the hygiene chair or over the phone, they’d hear the same confident answer.

Talking With Your Patients

For about six months, we talked with every single patient in person. We explained why we were making the change, how it would make their visits better and what they could expect to pay going forward.

Some patients were upset and left. We expected that. But the vast majority stayed. Being open and upfront, face to face, made all the difference. It gave us the ability to answer questions in real time and reassure patients that they were in the right place for their dental care.

How Losing Patients Made Us Better

Here’s something I didn’t fully expect: the patients we lost actually opened the door to something better. With more breathing room in the schedule, we invested in more training for our team, tightened up our systems and gave ourselves more time with each patient to really explain what was going on with their smile. We were also able to put money into high-value marketing to introduce new patients to the practice. We had the time in the schedule now to see them sooner too!

Patients noticed right away. They weren’t being rushed in and out anymore. They could settle in, get comfortable, ask questions and get real answers. They felt cared for, and they started telling their friends. Our online reviews took off, and word spread in local community groups and on social media.

At an insurance-driven office, it’s easy to feel like just a number. At a fee-for-service practice, you’re a real person with a smile worth caring for.

Over time, some of the patients who’d left started coming back. We noticed that the treatment plans from their new insurance-driven offices didn’t reflect what they really needed. When we looked them over, many were aggressive, which is a common side effect of the volume pressure the PPO model creates.

The Results

Yes, collections dipped a bit for the first six to twelve months. But after year one? Things really took off. Since we were keeping more of what we produced, we could reinvest in marketing to a wider area and in new technology that made appointments even better.

All those new patients meant we needed help, so we hired our first associate. They took on more of the routine dentistry, which freed up our main doctors to focus on bigger cases and keep growing their skills. That let us offer more services in-house and refer out a lot less. A year later, we hired a second associate. Within five years, we were a 3.5-doctor practice with four full-time hygiene chairs, and we were bursting at the seams. Collections grew from $2 million in 2016 to $6 million!

What I’d Tell Any Practice Owner

One big decision, made with conviction and backed by a team that believes in it, completely changed our practice. If you’re thinking about going fee-for-service, start by figuring out what your PPO contracts are really costing you. Compare your production to your collections; the gap might surprise you. Then plan for staffing and schedule changes before they happen, and bring your team in early so they become your biggest advocates. Talk openly with every patient, and use the extra time to invest in training, systems and a better patient experience. Give it six to twelve months, and stay the course.

At the end of the day, our success came down to investing in our team so they could champion the practice with every patient they met. Consistency, dedication and heart are what make any big change work.

Ready to explore your own path to fee-for-service? Reach out to Argyle Lift and let’s talk about a transition plan built around your practice’s numbers, team and patients.

Talk with Argyle Lift

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a fee-for-service dental practice?

It’s a practice that isn’t contracted with any dental insurance PPO networks. The practice sets its own fees, and patients pay the practice directly. Patients with insurance can still use their out-of-network benefits, usually by submitting a claim for reimbursement.

Will I lose patients if I drop my PPO contracts?

Probably some, and that’s normal. In our experience, most patients stayed when we explained the change clearly and in person, and some who left eventually came back. The lighter schedule also opened up room for new patients.

How much should I save before going out of network?

We recommend about three to six months of salaries and operating expenses. That cushion keeps you from making rushed decisions while collections settle.

How long does it take to bounce back after dropping PPOs?

We saw a small dip in collections for six to twelve months, then strong growth after the first year.

Can fee-for-service work in a lower-income area?

Yes! Our practice was in a relatively low-income area. What mattered was the quality of care, patient education and the experience we created. Patients will gladly pay for high-quality care when they feel valued.